“He that is without sin among you, let him first cast a stone.” John 8:7
Have you ever felt your heart skip when you almost got caught doing something you shouldn’t? That moment when time slows down and your mouth goes cotton-dry as you realize how close you came to exposure?
I was scrolling through my phone this morning, coffee steam warming my face, when the video appeared on my feed. You have probably seen it by now. A CEO and his HR manager, caught on a Coldplay kiss cam, scrambling to hide their faces as 50 million viewers watched their private moment become public shame. I could almost smell the arena’s mixture of excitement and sweat, feel the deafening roar of the crowd shifting from cheers to gasps in seconds.
The comments section was ruthless. Laughing emojis multiplying like cancer cells. Moral outrage. Righteous indignation served up in 280 characters or less. “They deserve everything they get.” “Play with fire, get burned.” “Finally, justice.” And for just a moment, I felt it too, that cold satisfaction of watching someone else’s failure from the safety of my own screen, the bitter taste of superiority coating my tongue. Until something uncomfortable stirred in my chest, like ice water in my veins. A whisper I didn’t want to hear, cutting through my judgment like a blade: This could be me.
The Weight of Hidden Moments
“The only way to deal with temptation is to yield to it.” – Oscar Wilde
We all have our concert moments. Maybe yours doesn’t involve a kiss cam and a stadium full of strangers, but we all have those seconds when our private compromises threaten to become public knowledge. Close your eyes for a moment, can you feel it? That last time you bent the truth to avoid an uncomfortable conversation, the metallic taste of deception on your tongue, the way your mouth went Sahara-dry as the lie left your lips. The moment when the fluorescent office lighting seemed too bright after you took credit for someone else’s idea, your pulse hammering against your collar as your colleagues nodded at “your” brilliance. Or perhaps it was that evening when you said “I love you too” to your spouse while your thumbs danced across your phone screen, typing words to someone else that made your chest tighten with guilt and excitement. Did your hands shake as you hit send? Did the familiar scent of your partner’s perfume suddenly feel suffocating?
These moments don’t live in headlines. They live in the spaces between what we project and who we are. They breathe in bathroom stalls with harsh lighting, where we delete messages and avoid our own reflection, looking like a stranger in the mirror. They ride along in cars that smell like morning coffee and evening regret, where we rehearse stories we hope will pass as truth. They hover in the three-second pause before we answer a phone call, as we decide which version of ourselves to present, our finger hovering over the green button like it holds the fate of our entire identity. As psychologist Dan Ariely discovered in his research on dishonesty, we deceive not just others, but ourselves, rationalizing small dishonest acts in ways that allow us to still see ourselves as good people. The only difference between us and Andy Byron isn’t moral superiority. It’s that our moments of weakness haven’t been broadcast to 50 million people, yet.
The Stones We Carry
“We are all in the gutter, but some of us are looking at the stars.” – Oscar Wilde
But when someone else’s failure goes viral, we transform. The air itself seems to change, thinner, charged with the electricity of collective judgment. Suddenly, we become the moral authority we have never managed to be in our own lives. We point fingers with the same hands that have stolen time, attention, and trust. We condemn with the same hearts that have harbored jealousy, greed, and deception like old friends. There’s something intoxicating about being the judge instead of the judged, isn’t there? It tastes like power. Like safety. Like the relief of being on the “right side” of shame for once.
It’s easier to focus on someone else’s exposed failure than to examine our own hidden ones. The spotlight on them creates a shadow for us, cool, protective darkness where we can hide from our own reflection. “Play stupid games, win stupid prizes,” one observer said about the couple, her words sharp as broken glass. And while there’s truth in consequences, there’s something else at work here: the relief that comes from watching someone else pay the price we have somehow avoided paying ourselves. Research on self-affirmation theory in psychology shows that we often judge others harshly as a way to protect our own self-image from uncomfortable truths. When someone else’s actions threaten how we see ourselves, it can feel safer to condemn than to confront what those actions reveal about our own flaws. But what if this public humiliation serves a purpose none of us expected? What if seeing their consequence becomes the wake-up call that saves someone else’s marriage? What if their exposed moment, raw and devastating as fresh roadkill, becomes the reason someone else chooses differently in their own private moment of temptation?
Imagine the spouse who watched this video and felt their own secret phone buzz with a message they shouldn’t answer. Picture them staring at that screen, seeing not strangers but themselves, and choosing to delete the conversation instead of diving deeper. Sometimes one person’s fall becomes another’s salvation. The price is still real. The pain is still devastating. But perhaps no failure is ever entirely wasted if it teaches the rest of us something about ourselves.
The Mirror We Don’t Want to Look Into
Here’s what made me uncomfortable about my initial reaction to that video: I recognized myself in it. Not in the infidelity, but in the capacity for it. In the ability to rationalize. In the small compromises that, unchecked, lead to larger ones. I saw myself in the scramble to hide, in the panic when private becomes public, in the desperation to control a narrative that’s already spinning beyond control. And maybe that’s the real scandal here, not what they did, but what their doing reveals about all of us. Our capacity for failure. Our ability to live double lives. Our talent for justifying what we know is wrong.
The CEO and his HR manager aren’t monsters. They are mirrors, reflecting back the parts of ourselves we would rather not acknowledge. The parts that are capable of hurting the people we claim to love most. The parts that choose momentary pleasure over lasting integrity.
The Choice Before Us
“Be kind, for everyone you meet is fighting a battle you know nothing about.” – Plato
So what do we do with this recognition? How do we respond when someone else’s failure forces us to confront our own capacity for the same? The question hangs in the air like smoke, impossible to wave away. We have two choices, really. Two paths that diverge in the yellow wood of our moral landscape.
The first is to maintain the distance. To keep pointing fingers and casting stones that feel smooth and righteous in our palms. To convince ourselves that we are different, better, more moral, to wrap ourselves in the warm blanket of superiority. It is the safer choice because it protects our self-image like armor. It lets us stay comfortable in the illusion of our own righteousness, breathing the thin air of moral high ground.
The second choice tastes like humble pie and feels like taking a step off a cliff. It asks us to see their failure as a preview of what we are all capable of under the right circumstances. To recognize that the only thing standing between us and our own viral moment might just be luck, timing, or the grace of not being caught in our own moment of weakness. This choice requires something that sticks in our throat like bitter medicine: empathy for people who have done something we condemn. It asks us to hold two truths simultaneously, like carrying fire and ice in the same hands, that actions have consequences, and that the person facing those consequences is still human. Still struggling. Still worthy of the same grace we hope for when our own failures inevitably come to light like photographs in a developing room.
Also Read: When the Ones Who Hurt Us Become the Ones We Pray For
What We are All Figuring Out Together
“I have learned throughout my life as a composer chiefly through my mistakes and pursuits of false assumptions, not by my exposure to founts of wisdom and knowledge.” – Igor Stravinsky
None of us signed up for this life with an instruction manual. We are all improvising, making choices based on incomplete information and imperfect judgment, like actors in a play where no one gave us the script. Sometimes we choose well, and the applause feels like warm sunshine. Sometimes we don’t, and the silence cuts like winter wind. Sometimes we get caught, our mistakes displayed under fluorescent lights for all to see. Sometimes we don’t, and we carry the weight of our secrets like stones in our pockets.
But here is what I have learned from my own failures, the ones that left scars on my heart and the ones that taught me who I really am, and from watching others face theirs: the goal isn’t to be perfect. It’s to be honest about our imperfection. To acknowledge that we are all capable of the same stupid, selfish, shortsighted decisions that hurt the people we love, like friendly fire in the war of life.
Picture Andy Byron tonight. The house that once smelled like home now thick with the stench of consequence. His children’s eyes holding questions he can’t answer. His wife’s silence louder than screaming. The weight of fifty million judgments pressing down on his chest like he is drowning in plain sight.
The CEO will face consequences that taste like ash and feel like carrying boulders. His family will experience pain sharp as broken glass. The HR manager will rebuild her life from the pieces, each fragment cutting her hands as she tries to make something whole again. This is as it should be, actions have weight, and that weight must be carried like gravity itself.
But somewhere in the midst of their public shame, maybe something good can emerge. Maybe their fall prevents someone else’s. Maybe their exposed moment becomes the mirror that helps the rest of us see more clearly. Maybe their consequence becomes someone else’s course correction.
The Sacred Pause
“Before you embark on a journey of revenge, dig two graves.” – Confucius
What questions do you ask yourself in the darkness of 3 AM when sleep won’t come? When your own choices stare back at you from the ceiling like accusations written in invisible ink? The next time you see someone’s failure go viral, and there will be a next time, because this is the world we have built, before you comment, before you judge, before you feel that cold satisfaction of not being them, pause. Let the moment breathe like a prayer between heartbeats.
Ask yourself the questions that cut deeper than headlines: What would I want people to think about me if my worst moment was broadcast to millions? Would I want them to see a monster, or a human being who made a terrible choice that tastes like poison in my mouth? Would I want them to throw stones that bruise and break, or extend the kind of grace I hope to receive when my own failures come to light like sunrise after the darkest night? Would I want them to write me off completely, to erase every good thing I have ever done with the red ink of this one mistake, or remember that we are all figuring this out together, stumbling through this maze of choices with no map and no guarantee?
A Story We Are All Living
Imagine yourself in that arena. Feel the lights burning your face. Hear the crowd’s gasp echo in your chest like thunder. Smell your own fear, sharp and metallic. Taste the panic, bitter as black coffee. Feel your heart hammering against your ribs like it’s trying to escape. This is what it means to be human. This is what it looks like when our private selves collide with public consequences. This is the price of being imperfect in a world obsessed with perfection.
The CEO and his HR manager made choices that hurt people they claimed to love. That’s not debatable. The pain is as real as broken bones. The consequences are deserved, like rain after a drought. But in the end, they are not villains in someone else’s story. They are characters in the same story we are all living. A story that smells like coffee and regret, that tastes like hope and desperation, that feels like trying to find our way home in the dark. A story about imperfect people making imperfect choices while trying to love well and live with integrity in a world that offers neither instruction manual nor second chances.
Some chapters end badly, with the metallic taste of consequence and the cold weight of judgment. Some consequences are public and permanent as tattoos. But the story isn’t over, not for them, and not for us who watch from the sidelines, grateful it wasn’t our turn in the spotlight.
As Maya Angelou once said, “There is no greater agony than bearing an untold story inside you.” Perhaps their story, now told against their will, becomes the catalyst for our own untold stories to find redemption. The question that hangs in the air like morning mist is this: What will we choose to learn from their chapter as we write our own?
Reflection
What moments in your own life have taught you the most about grace, either receiving it or extending it? What stories do you carry that remind you of your own capacity for both failure and redemption? I would love to hear your thoughts in the comments below, because we are all figuring this out together.
And if this story resonated with you, share it. Tell someone. And if you want more stories that open your heart, deepen your vision, and guide your growth, subscribe to Ascent to Virtue. We are all walking each other home.
